Ontario’s non-compete ban: what founders can still put in an employment agreement
Written by Brooke Ash, lawyer at For Founders Law.
In short
Since October 25, 2021, Ontario's Employment Standards Act has prohibited employers from entering into non-compete agreements with employees, with exceptions for certain sales of a business and for listed executive roles. Founders can still protect the company with confidentiality terms, IP assignments and carefully drafted non-solicitation clauses, but a template non-compete from another province or the US will usually not help.
A founder hiring a first engineer or salesperson often asks the same question: can we stop this person from joining a competitor if they leave? In Ontario, for most employees, the answer is no. That doesn’t leave the company unprotected, but the protection comes from other terms.
This post is general information, not legal advice.
What the ban says
Section 67.2 of Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 says an employer must not enter into an employment contract or other agreement with an employee that is, or includes, a non-compete. The ESA defines a non-compete as an agreement that prohibits the employee from engaging in a business, work, occupation, profession, project or other activity that competes with the employer’s business after the employment ends.
The ban applies to agreements entered into on or after October 25, 2021. If such a term is in the agreement anyway, the employer can’t rely on it, and an employee can file a claim with the Ministry of Labour (Ontario’s ESA guide). Agreements made before that date aren’t caught by the ban but are still tested under the common law.
Note the words “or other agreement.” A non-compete with an employee is unlikely to be saved just because it sits in a side letter, an option grant or a shareholder agreement instead of the employment contract, although how the ban applies to agreements signed in a person’s capacity as a shareholder isn’t fully settled. If a founder or early hire is both a shareholder and an employee, get advice on how the restrictive covenants in your shareholder agreement are written.
The two exceptions
The ESA allows a non-compete in two situations:
- Sale of a business. When a business, or part of it, is sold and the seller becomes an employee of the buyer immediately after the sale, the buyer and seller can agree to a non-compete.
- Executives. A non-compete is allowed with an employee who holds an executive position listed in the ESA, such as chief executive officer, president, chief administrative officer, chief operating officer, chief financial officer, chief information officer, chief legal officer, chief human resources officer or chief corporate development officer, or any other chief executive position.
Even where the ESA allows a non-compete, a court still has to find it reasonable before it will enforce it. A title alone doesn’t make a broad restriction enforceable.
What you can still use
Confidentiality. A clear confidentiality clause protects your source code, customer lists, pricing, product roadmap and investor terms during and after employment. This is often the term that actually matters when someone leaves for a competitor.
IP assignment. Under the Copyright Act, an employer is generally the first owner of copyright in work an employee makes in the course of employment. Inventions, work done outside the job description and work done before the start date are less clear, so a written IP assignment and a moral rights waiver belong in every employment agreement. See who owns code a contractor writes.
Non-solicitation. A non-solicitation clause stops a former employee from approaching your customers or poaching your team for a period after they leave. It isn’t banned by section 67.2, but it must be reasonable in scope and length, and it shouldn’t be drafted so broadly that it works like a non-compete in practice.
Return of property and accounts. Require the return of devices, documents and credentials, and the transfer of any company accounts the employee set up.
What about contractors?
Section 67.2 applies to employees. A true independent contractor falls outside the ESA, and restrictions in a contractor agreement are tested under the general law on restraint of trade, which is also skeptical of broad non-competes. Calling someone a contractor to get around the ban doesn’t work if the relationship is really employment. See employee or contractor.
A quick checklist
- Remove non-competes from templates you use for non-executive Ontario employees.
- Make sure confidentiality and IP assignment terms are in place and signed before the first day.
- Keep any non-solicit narrow: named activities, a defined period and customers the employee actually dealt with.
- Review restrictive covenants in your shareholder agreement and option documents if your shareholders are also employees.
- Treat executive non-competes as an exception to be drafted carefully, not a default.
We draft employment agreements and contractor agreements at fixed fees, listed on our fees page. If you’d like to talk through your situation, book a free 15-minute consult.
Sources
How we can help
- Shareholder AgreementWho decides what, and what happens if a founder leaves. From $1,320
- Employment AgreementFor your first and next employees. From $640
Fixed fees. Government filing fees are extra.