Do stores have to accept returns in Ontario?
Written by Brooke Ash, lawyer at For Founders Law.
Short answer
No. Ontario law doesn’t give shoppers a general right to return an item that isn’t defective, so your store policy decides. That policy has to be honest and disclosed, and it can’t take away rights the law gives consumers, such as the right to goods of acceptable quality. Online sales have extra rules, including a right to cancel if you don’t give the required disclosures or a copy of the agreement, or if you deliver more than 30 days late.
We can help at a fixed fee: Terms of Service, from $500. Book a free 15-minute consult
January is returns season. Customers often believe they have a legal right to bring back any gift, and many owners aren’t sure what they have to accept. This is general information about Ontario law, not legal advice.
Do stores have to accept returns in Ontario?
Not for an item that simply isn’t wanted. Ontario’s own guidance says the Consumer Protection Act, 2002 doesn’t give a general right to return or exchange goods. If a sweater is the wrong size or the customer changed their mind, your policy decides whether they get a refund, an exchange, store credit or nothing.
That freedom has limits:
- The policy must be honest. Under the Act, a false, misleading or deceptive representation is an unfair practice, and that includes a statement that a sale does or doesn’t involve rights or remedies when that isn’t true (s. 14). Under the federal Competition Act, a court deciding whether a representation is false or misleading considers the general impression it creates, not only its literal words (general impression test). If your ad says “easy returns” and the fine print says final sale, you have a problem.
- The policy must be disclosed. For online sales, it is part of the required disclosure before checkout (see below). In a physical store, post it at the till and print it on the receipt, so customers see it before they pay.
- The policy can’t take away legal rights. The Act’s rights apply despite any agreement or waiver to the contrary (s. 7).
What if the item is defective?
Then your policy isn’t the last word. Goods supplied under a consumer agreement carry the implied conditions and warranties of the Sale of Goods Act, and services are deemed to be of reasonably acceptable quality (s. 9). Under the Sale of Goods Act, goods bought by description from a seller who deals in them must be of merchantable quality, and goods must be reasonably fit for a purpose the buyer made known and relied on the seller for.
Any term that tries to negate or vary those conditions is void (s. 9(3)). So “all sales final” can stop a change-of-mind return. It can’t stop a customer’s claim for a product that doesn’t work. The law doesn’t set one fixed fix, like a refund within a set number of days, for every defect. What the customer can recover depends on the facts. Most businesses handle defects through repair, replacement or refund, and a clear warranty policy helps.
What extra rules apply to online orders?
Most online sales to consumers are internet agreements. When the customer could pay more than $50, ss. 38 to 40 and O. Reg. 17/05 apply. Before the customer buys, you must disclose prescribed information, including your cancellation, return, exchange and refund policies. You must also give an express chance to accept, decline or correct errors, and send a copy of the agreement within 15 days.
If you miss those steps, the customer can cancel, whatever your return policy says:
| What went wrong | The customer can cancel |
|---|---|
| Required information not disclosed, or no chance to accept, decline or correct errors (s. 40(1)) | From the date of the agreement until 7 days after they receive a copy |
| No copy of the agreement delivered as required (s. 40(2)) | Within 30 days after the agreement was made |
| Goods not delivered within 30 days after the delivery date in the agreement (s. 26(1)) | Any time before delivery |
| No delivery date given, and goods not delivered within 30 days of the order (s. 26(2)) | Any time before delivery |
The late delivery right comes from the rules on future performance agreements, which cover any sale where delivery or full payment happens after the order (s. 26). If the customer accepts delivery after the 30 days have run out, they lose that right to cancel (s. 26(3)). A delivery attempt that the customer refused, or that failed because no one was there after reasonable notice, counts as delivery (s. 26(4)). For holiday orders, put a realistic delivery date at checkout.
How fast do I have to refund after a cancellation?
Within 15 days after the customer gives notice that they are cancelling (s. 96; reg. s. 79). The notice can be given in any way that shows they want to cancel (s. 92). For a cancelled internet agreement, the customer returns the goods within 15 days, using a method that confirms delivery, and you pay the reasonable cost of the return (reg. s. 81). For digital goods, you can instead give written directions to destroy them (reg. s. 81(5)).
Can the customer ask their credit card company to reverse the charge?
Yes. If the customer cancelled under the Act and you don’t refund within the required time, they can ask their card issuer in writing to reverse the charge (s. 99). The request goes to the issuer within 60 days after your refund deadline passed. The issuer must acknowledge it within 30 days. Then, by the customer’s second statement, it must either reverse the charge or explain in writing why it won’t (reg. s. 85). This is separate from the card networks’ own dispute rules. Refunding on time is the easiest way to avoid both.
Are gift receipts and store-credit-only policies allowed?
Yes, as policy choices. You can limit gift receipt returns to exchange or store credit, and refund to the original payment method only. Say so on the receipt and in your policy. If you issue store credit on a card, state clearly whether it expires. The gift card rules don’t expressly deal with store credit, so get advice before you put an expiry date on it. Gift cards themselves have their own rules: see can gift cards expire in Ontario?
Do I have to extend my return window over the holidays?
No. An extended holiday window, such as returns until January 15 for purchases made from November 15, is a business choice. If you offer one, state the exact dates and what’s excluded. Then honour it as written.
Is a “final sale” or “no refunds” sign enough?
For change-of-mind returns, a clear and visible final sale sign is generally enough. It doesn’t override defect rights or the online cancellation rights above, and it shouldn’t suggest it does. A sign saying “no refunds under any circumstances” can mislead customers about their rights. “All sales final. This does not affect your rights for defective goods” is safer wording.
What about digital goods and subscriptions?
Digital products sold online are internet agreements too, so the same disclosure, copy and cancellation rules apply. Subscriptions also raise renewal and cancellation questions. See subscription and cancellation laws in Canada.
A holiday return policy checklist for an online store
- Show your return, exchange and refund policy before checkout, and in the confirmation email.
- State any holiday return window with exact dates.
- Spell out what’s final sale, and keep the defective goods carve-out.
- Give a realistic delivery date for each order.
- Send the order confirmation, with the agreement, right away.
- Set up a way to issue refunds within 15 days of a valid cancellation.
- Make sure your ads and banners match the policy.
What to do next
We draft terms of service and refund policies that fit Ontario consumer rules, and review checkout flows and platform terms through a contract review, at fixed fees on our fees page. For holiday promotions, see holiday sale pricing rules and online terms and Ontario consumer law.
A free holiday check. Bring your return policy and checkout page to a free 15-minute call and we’ll tell you what to fix before January. Book your holiday check, or send us your return policy.
Sources
- Consumer Protection Act, 2002 (Ontario), s. 7 (no waiver of rights)
- Consumer Protection Act, 2002, s. 9 (quality of goods and services)
- Consumer Protection Act, 2002, s. 14 (false, misleading or deceptive representations)
- Consumer Protection Act, 2002, s. 26 (cancelling for late delivery)
- Consumer Protection Act, 2002, ss. 37 to 40 (internet agreements)
- Consumer Protection Act, 2002, s. 96 (supplier's obligations on cancellation)
- Consumer Protection Act, 2002, s. 99 (credit card charge reversal)
- O. Reg. 17/05 (General), ss. 31 to 33 (internet agreements)
- O. Reg. 17/05 (General), ss. 79, 81 and 85 (refunds, returns and credit card requests after cancellation)
- Sale of Goods Act (Ontario), s. 15 (implied conditions of quality and fitness)
- Government of Ontario: Returns, exchanges and warranties in Ontario
- Government of Ontario: Advice on shopping online or over the phone
- Competition Bureau: The general impression test
Citation copied
How we can help
- IncorporationFederal or Ontario, set up properly the first time. From $600
- Shareholder AgreementWho decides what, and what happens if a founder leaves. From $1,320
Fixed fees. Government filing fees are extra.