Can my marketplace hold buyer payments until delivery in Canada?
Written by Brooke Ash, lawyer at For Founders Law.
Short answer
You can build it that way, but it changes your legal position. Under the Bank of Canada's December 2025 policy for online marketplaces, a marketplace that receives buyer payments into an account it owns or controls, or holds sale proceeds before paying sellers, is generally performing payment activities under the Retail Payment Activities Act and is expected to register with the Bank and safeguard those funds. A marketplace whose payment provider handles the money end to end, without the marketplace ever taking custody, may fall outside the Act. Decide the payment flow with your provider before you write your terms.
We can help at a fixed fee: Contract Review, from $400. Book a free 15-minute consult
Holding the buyer’s money until the item arrives is one of the most common ideas we hear from marketplace founders. It builds trust on both sides. It also puts you inside a federal payments law that many founders haven’t heard of. This is general information about Canadian law, not legal advice.
Which law applies?
The Retail Payment Activities Act (RPAA) regulates payment service providers, and the Bank of Canada supervises it. A business that performs payment functions as a service or business activity, such as holding funds for an end user, initiating or authorizing transfers, or clearing and settling them, generally has to register with the Bank, manage operational risk and safeguard end user funds. Registration opened in November 2024 and the full obligations have applied since September 2025.
When is a marketplace a payment service provider?
In December 2025 the Bank published a policy for online marketplaces. In short:
- Money in your account. A marketplace that receives buyer funds into a bank account it owns or controls, as part of the flow between buyers and third-party sellers, is generally performing payment activities under the Act.
- Money at rest. If sale proceeds sit with the marketplace before they are paid out to sellers, the marketplace is also holding funds. The Bank says funds are still at rest even when payouts run on a fixed schedule.
- Using a provider doesn’t end the analysis. A marketplace can still be a payment service provider when it contracts with another provider for parts of the payment process.
- “Incidental” is narrow here. The Act has an exclusion for payment functions that are incidental to another business. The Bank’s view is that a marketplace directly in the flow of funds isn’t incidental, even if it holds money only for fraud checks, dispute resolution or fee collection.
- Where a marketplace may be outside the Act. If third-party payment providers handle the money end to end and the marketplace never takes custody of end users’ funds, its role may be limited to data and support services.
The policy covers sales by third-party sellers. If you also sell your own products, the Act applies only to the payment functions for third-party sales.
So can I hold the money until delivery?
There are generally three ways to build it:
| Approach | What it means for you |
|---|---|
| Your payment provider holds the funds in the seller’s own account, and releases them on your instruction | Often the simplest. Whether you are outside the Act depends on the exact flow and who controls the accounts, so confirm it in writing with your provider |
| Funds come into your own account or balance, and you pay sellers later | You are likely a payment service provider. Expect registration with the Bank, safeguarding of funds and risk management duties |
| A separate escrow or trust arrangement with a regulated third party | Possible for high-value transactions, at a cost |
The brand of provider doesn’t decide this. The same provider can be set up in more than one way, for example with the money landing in the seller’s connected account or in the platform’s own balance. Ask your provider which flow you are on, who legally holds the funds at each step, and what they will confirm in writing.
What should my terms say?
Whatever the flow, your terms should match it:
- who the buyer is paying, and when the seller is paid;
- when funds are released, and what counts as delivery or acceptance;
- how refunds, chargebacks and disputes work, and who bears each;
- your fees and when they are deducted; and
- what happens to funds if an account is suspended.
Promising “your money is protected until delivery” when the provider, not you, controls the release is the kind of statement that creates liability. See is a marketplace liable for its sellers?
Anything else?
- Tax reporting. Many digital platform operators must report seller income to the CRA each January under the reporting rules for digital platforms, and some must collect GST/HST on sales by sellers who aren’t registered. Ask your accountant how these apply to your model.
- Anti-money laundering rules can apply to some payment and money transfer businesses. If you plan to move money between users outside a sale, get advice first.
- Incorporate first. Sign with your payment provider as a company, not personally.
What to do next
We review payment provider agreements through a contract review and write platform terms of service that match how your money actually moves. The Platform Launch Pack on our fees page includes the terms, a privacy policy and your cofounder agreement. See everything we do for marketplaces and platforms.
Choosing a payment setup? Bring your provider and your planned flow to a free 15-minute call. Book a free consult, or send us a note.
Sources
Citation copied
How we can help
- IncorporationFederal or Ontario, set up properly the first time. From $600
- Shareholder AgreementWho decides what, and what happens if a founder leaves. From $1,320
Fixed fees. Government filing fees are extra.