Is a marketplace liable for what its sellers and users do in Canada?

Last reviewed

Written by Brooke Ash, lawyer at For Founders Law.

Short answer

Not automatically. A marketplace that only connects buyers and sellers usually isn't the seller, so the seller answers for the product or service. But Canada has no blanket shield like the US Section 230, so a platform can be liable for its own promises, its own advertising and how it presents listings, and it can face claims over user posts once it knows about them and does nothing. Clear terms, a way to report problems and a habit of acting on reports are the main protections.

We can help at a fixed fee: Terms of Service, from $500. Book a free 15-minute consult

Most marketplace founders ask this question after something goes wrong: a buyer gets a broken item, a seller lists something they shouldn’t, or a user posts a review that someone says is false. The better time to ask is before launch, because most of the answer depends on how you build the platform and what your terms say. This is general information about Canadian and Ontario law, not legal advice.

Who is the seller?

On most marketplaces, the seller is the person or business that lists the item or service, and the buyer’s contract for the item is with them. The platform provides the place, the tools and often the payment flow, and it earns a fee.

That split only holds if the platform behaves like it. If your site presents items as yours, sets the prices, holds the stock, chooses who fulfils the order or promises the result, a buyer or a court may treat you as the seller or as a party to the sale. Say clearly, in your terms and at checkout, who the buyer is buying from.

Is there a Canadian version of Section 230?

No. In the United States, Section 230 broadly protects platforms from liability for what users post. Canada has no general statute like it. Liability for user content here is decided case by case, mostly under the ordinary law of defamation, privacy, intellectual property and consumer protection.

Two points come up often. The Supreme Court of Canada held in Crookes v. Newton that a hyperlink alone isn’t publication of the linked content. And courts have treated hosts and intermediaries differently once they are told about unlawful content and leave it up. That is why a working report button and a written process for acting on reports matter more in Canada than founders expect.

What can a platform be liable for directly?

The risks that land on the platform itself usually come from what the platform says and does, not from what sellers do:

RiskExample
Your own promises“Every seller is verified” or “guaranteed delivery” when that isn’t true
Your own advertising and pricingAdvertising a price and adding a mandatory platform fee at checkout. The Competition Act treats most of these “drip pricing” practices as misleading
Reviews and ratings you controlRemoving negative reviews, or allowing fake ones, can mislead buyers
PrivacyYou are usually responsible for the personal information your platform collects, including ID checks, messages and payout details
PaymentsIf buyer money moves through an account you control, you may be a payment service provider. See holding buyer funds
Intellectual propertyLeaving up listings that copy someone’s trademark or photos after you have been told about them

What about consumer law?

If sellers on your platform sell to consumers in Ontario, the Consumer Protection Act, 2002 usually applies to those sales, including its rules for internet agreements, disclosure and refunds. Whether your platform is also a “supplier” depends on how you present and run the sale. Some terms can’t be enforced against Ontario consumers at all, such as a clause forcing every dispute into private arbitration. See Ontario consumer law and online terms.

How do marketplaces reduce the risk?

  1. Terms for both sides. Buyer terms that say who they are buying from and what the platform does and doesn’t guarantee, and seller terms with listing rules, prohibited items, fees, payouts and removal rights. See platform terms versus seller terms.
  2. An acceptable use policy that you actually enforce. See what an acceptable use policy should cover.
  3. A report button and a process. Who reviews reports, how fast, what gets removed and what gets recorded.
  4. Accurate marketing. Only promise checks, guarantees or protections you deliver every time.
  5. Seller responsibility and indemnity clauses, so sellers carry the cost of claims caused by their own listings. These help, but only as far as the seller can pay.
  6. A company, not you personally. Incorporate before you take your first transaction, so contracts and claims sit with the business.
  7. Insurance. Ask a broker about general liability, cyber and errors and omissions coverage for a platform.

What about sellers who are individuals?

Many marketplaces have casual sellers, not businesses. Consumer protection rules generally apply to businesses selling to consumers, so a sale between two individuals may fall outside them, while your platform’s own terms with each of them still apply. Separate rules can also apply to the platform itself, such as Ontario’s rules for app-based ride share, delivery and courier work (see the Digital Platform Workers’ Rights Act) and the CRA’s reporting rules for digital platform operators.

What to do next

We write platform terms of service for buyers and sellers, privacy policies for two-sided platforms, and review your payment provider’s terms through a contract review. The Platform Launch Pack on our fees page puts the terms, privacy policy and your cofounder agreement together at one fixed fee. See everything we do for marketplaces and platforms.

Launching soon? Tell us how your platform works and when it goes live on a free 15-minute call, and we’ll tell you what to put in place first. Book a free consult, or send us a note.

Sources

  1. Crookes v. Newton, 2011 SCC 47 (hyperlinks and publication)
  2. Competition Act (Canada), ss. 52 and 74.01 (misleading representations, including drip pricing)
  3. Consumer Protection Act, 2002 (Ontario)
  4. Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA)

How we can help

Fixed fees. Government filing fees are extra.