Can a clinic use an AI scribe? Consent, vendors and PHIPA in Ontario

· Last reviewed

Written by Brooke Ash, lawyer at For Founders Law.

A health professional's hands at a wooden desk with a laptop, a stethoscope and an apple.
A clinician’s desk, with a laptop alongside the stethoscope. Photo: Shixart1985, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons, cropped.

In short

AI scribes that record a visit and draft clinical notes handle personal health information, so in Ontario they bring in PHIPA for health information custodians, and PIPEDA for many wellness businesses that aren't custodians. The Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario's January 2026 guidance says consent would generally be required, and it expects clinics to assess vendors, limit what is kept and stop vendors from using the data for their own purposes. Clinicians stay responsible for the accuracy of the record.

AI scribes listen to a client visit, transcribe it and draft a note for the practitioner to review. Clinics, physiotherapy practices, therapists and naturopaths are adopting them to cut charting time. Before you switch one on, you need to deal with consent, the vendor contract and what happens to the recordings.

This post is general information, not legal advice.

Which law applies to you

If you’re a health information custodian under Ontario’s PHIPA, such as a regulated health professional or the operator of a group practice, PHIPA governs how you collect, use and disclose personal health information. A visit recording, its transcript and the note drafted from it all contain it.

Many wellness businesses aren’t custodians: for example, a coaching service or wellness app run by people who aren’t regulated health professionals. Those businesses are generally covered by PIPEDA (section 4) when they handle personal information in commercial activity, and health information is treated as sensitive, which raises the standard for consent. See privacy for clinics and wellness brands.

What the IPC said in January 2026

The Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario published AI Scribes: Key Considerations for the Health Sector and a companion checklist on January 28, 2026. Its main points for custodians:

  • Consent. The IPC’s view is that no PHIPA provision specifically permits collecting, using or disclosing personal health information through an AI scribe without consent, so consent would generally be required. Clients should understand that the visit will be recorded and processed with AI, what’s collected, that a vendor is involved, and the main risks and benefits. A client who says no should get the same care.
  • Vendor assessment. Assess how the system is built, where data goes and how it’s protected before you sign, and do a privacy impact assessment.
  • Limits on vendor use. Use contracts and system settings to stop the vendor from using recordings, transcripts or notes for its own purposes, including training its models.
  • Data minimization. Ask whether you need to keep full audio or transcripts once the note is final.
  • Governance. Have written policies, training, and ongoing monitoring of how the tool performs.

The vendor contract

Most AI scribe vendors are software companies using their own standard terms, which are often written for US customers. Before you sign, look for:

  • Where data is stored and processed, and which sub-processors the vendor uses
  • A clear prohibition on using your data to train or improve models, unless you’ve decided otherwise with proper consent
  • How long recordings and transcripts are kept, and how you can have them deleted
  • Security commitments and how fast the vendor must tell you about a breach
  • What happens to your data if you cancel or the vendor is sold

A data processing agreement or similar addendum is where many of these terms sit. Under PHIPA (section 17), a custodian remains responsible for personal health information handled on its behalf by its agents, so the contract should give you the controls the law expects you to have. We review vendor agreements as a contract review.

The record is still yours

An AI-drafted note is a draft. The practitioner signing it is responsible for its accuracy, and your regulatory college’s record-keeping standards still apply. Build review into the workflow: check medications, dosages, names and anything said in a hurry. Decide whether the client’s record will show that an AI tool was used.

If something goes wrong

Under PHIPA (section 12), a custodian must notify the affected individual at the first reasonable opportunity if personal health information is stolen, lost or used or disclosed without authority, and must report certain incidents to the IPC in the circumstances set out in O. Reg. 329/04. A vendor’s security incident can trigger these duties, which is why the notice terms in your contract matter.

A starting checklist

  • Decide which law applies to your practice.
  • Update your consent forms and privacy notice to cover AI scribes, and record each client’s choice.
  • Review the vendor’s terms and get the contract terms you need.
  • Turn off model training and set the shortest workable retention period.
  • Train staff on reviewing AI-drafted notes before they’re signed.

Our clinic privacy and consent work covers your privacy policy, intake and consent forms, and a review against PHIPA, at a fixed fee listed on our fees page. To talk through an AI tool you’re considering, book a free 15-minute consult.

Sources

  1. Aird & Berlis: The rise of AI scribes, balancing efficiency with privacy (summary of the IPC guidance)
  2. Personal Health Information Protection Act, 2004 (Ontario)
  3. IPC Ontario: AI Scribes, Key Considerations for the Health Sector (January 28, 2026)
  4. IPC Ontario: AI Scribes, Checklist of Key Considerations for the Health Sector (January 28, 2026)
  5. PIPEDA, S.C. 2000, c. 5

How we can help

Fixed fees. Government filing fees are extra.